i Love New York Pizza Menu & Prices 2025 Guide

i Love New York Pizza Menu : A Slice Above the Rest

There’s something different about New York pizza. It’s not just the crust or the cheese—it’s the attitude, the pride, and the tradition baked into every slice. When I first walked into an I Love New York Pizza location years ago, I didn’t expect to become a regular. But there I was, one bite in, and already planning my next visit.

The i love new york pizza menu isn’t just a list of items—it’s a story. Each pizza tells its own tale. From the classic cheese that feels like home to the specialty pies that challenge the taste buds, this menu captures everything people love about real, honest food.

And whether you’re in Albany, Clifton Park, or Chapel Hill, there’s one thing you can count on: consistency. No fluff, no gimmicks—just pizza done right. In this guide, I’ll walk you through what’s actually on the menu, what’s worth ordering, and why this spot has a cult following across states.

But first—let’s clear one thing up: this isn’t some trendy pizza chain riding the New York name. It’s a real neighborhood staple where locals eat, students crave, and late-night cravings are cured. That’s what makes this guide not just useful—but necessary.

What’s on the i Love New York Pizza Menu? Full Breakdown of Pies, Prices & Popular Picks

If you’ve ever stared at the i love new york pizza menu wondering whether to go with a plain cheese or something piled with toppings—trust me, you’re not alone. This place keeps it old-school but delivers more options than you’d expect. Let’s break it down so you know exactly what you’re getting when you place your order.

Classic New York-Style Pizza

You can’t go wrong with a good old-fashioned cheese slice. It’s what built the brand. Hand-tossed, thin crust, slightly crisp at the bottom but foldable—just how it should be.

Popular Options:

• Cheese Pizza (S/M/L): Starting at $9.99
• Pepperoni Pizza: From $11.49
• Sausage or Meatball Pizza: Around $12.99
• Combo (Meat Lovers / Supreme): $14.99+

The large 18-inch pies are generously sized, and yes—you can buy by the slice too. In most locations, a cheese or pepperoni slice will cost you between $2.75 and $3.50, depending on the city.

Specialty Pizzas Worth Trying

Each location features some local specialties, but here are the stars that show up on most menus:

• Buffalo Chicken Pizza – Crispy chicken, hot sauce, ranch swirl
• White Pizza – Ricotta, mozzarella, garlic (no red sauce)
• BBQ Chicken Pizza – Tangy sauce, grilled chicken, red onions
• Vegetarian Delight – Mushrooms, peppers, onions, olives, tomatoes

Prices for specialty pies usually range from $13.99 to $17.99, depending on toppings and size.

Build-Your-Own Pizza

Want to get creative? You can fully customize your pie with these toppings:

Meats:

• Pepperoni, Sausage, Bacon, Chicken, Ham, Meatball

Veggies:

• Spinach, Mushrooms, Broccoli, Black Olives, Tomatoes, Peppers, Onions

Each topping adds $1–$2, and gluten-free crust is available in select branches.

Calzones, Stromboli & Rolls

It’s not just about pizza. You’ll also find hand-rolled dough stuffed with cheeses, meats, and sauces.

• Calzones – Filled with ricotta, mozzarella, and your choice of filling
• Stromboli – Like a pizza burrito, often packed with pepperoni or sausage
• Chicken or Pepperoni Rolls – Great for on-the-go meals

Prices range from $6.99 to $9.99 depending on size and stuffing.

Pasta Dishes

Some locations (like Albany) serve hearty pasta trays. Expect options like:

• Baked Ziti
• Spaghetti with Meatballs
• Fettuccine Alfredo
• Lasagna

Plates range from $7.99 to $11.99 and come with garlic bread.

Wings & Sides

Craving more? You’ll usually see:

• Chicken Wings (Buffalo, BBQ, Garlic Parmesan) – $7.99–$11.99
• Garlic Knots – Soft, buttery, and addictive ($3.99–$5.99)
• Mozzarella Sticks – A crowd-pleaser at $6.99
• French Fries – Classic or loaded options

Desserts & Beverages

Finish strong with:

• New York Cheesecake – Rich and creamy, $3.99 per slice
• Cannoli – A sweet bite of Italy
• Soda & Iced Tea – Pepsi products usually on tap

### i Love New York Pizza Albany Menu: What Locals Are Actually Ordering

The i love new york pizza albany menu is one of the most popular for a reason—it’s built around student favorites, fast service, and seriously good flavor. Albany, being a college town, means two things: late-night cravings and picky eaters. And somehow, this spot satisfies both.

Whether you’re a SUNY student, a downtown local, or just passing through, this place has something that’ll hit the spot.

Fan-Favorites on the Albany Menu

• Giant Cheese Slices – Big enough to fold twice. Price hovers around $2.99–$3.25 per slice.
• Buffalo Chicken Pizza – Spicy, creamy, and loaded. Always a top-seller.
• The “Albany Combo” – A local twist on the meat lover’s with bacon, sausage, and jalapeños.
• White Pizza with Broccoli – Surprisingly refreshing and not too heavy.

Meal Deals & Lunch Combos

They offer daily combos that are easy on the wallet:

• 2 slices + drink combo – Around $6.99
• 1 slice + 5 garlic knots + drink – About $7.50
• Personal Pie + Soda – Starting at $9.99

And yes, they deliver fast across Albany NY, especially near student housing areas and Lark Street.

Unique Offerings at This Location

Unlike other branches, Albany sometimes features rotating specials like:

• Mac ‘n Cheese Pizza (yes, it’s as wild as it sounds)
• Sriracha Chicken Pie
• Deep-Dish options during winter months

They also host “Midnight Slice Deals” for students burning the midnight oil—buy 1 slice, get 1 half off after 10 PM.

Pricing Snapshot (Albany NY)

### i Love New York Pizza Chapel Hill Menu: A Slice of NY in the South

When you hear “New York pizza” in North Carolina, your first instinct might be to raise an eyebrow. But once you try a slice from the i love new york pizza chapel hill menu, you’ll understand why this place has won over students, locals, and even skeptical native New Yorkers.

Tucked conveniently near the University of North Carolina, this shop serves fast, friendly, and flavorful pies with no frills—just the kind of food you want after a long day (or night).

Local Favorites at the Chapel Hill Location

• Classic Cheese Slice – Thin, gooey, and foldable—just $3.25.
• The Tar Heel Special – A Chapel Hill-only pie with grilled chicken, jalapeños, red onions, and ranch drizzle.
• BBQ Bacon Pizza – Sweet and smoky with a crispy finish. It sells out fast.
• Spinach & Ricotta White Pie – No sauce, all flavor. A creamy vegetarian hit.

Lunch Combos & Late-Night Bites

They understand campus life here. That’s why most combos are tailored for solo eaters on a budget:

• Slice + Drink – Around $4.99
• 2 Slices + Drink – $7.50
• Small Pie + Garlic Knots + Can Soda – Under $10

Bonus: They stay open late on weekends. Midnight pizza in sweatpants? Yes, please.

Unique Perks at Chapel Hill

• Free Garlic Knots Fridays – Buy any large pie, get a 6-piece side free.
• Student Discount (with ID) – 10% off any order, anytime.
• Vegan Cheese Option – One of the few branches offering this.

Price Guide – Chapel Hill

### i Love New York Pizza Clifton Park Menu: Family-Friendly, Fast, and Full of Flavor

Clifton Park might not scream “pizza capital,” but locals know where to go when they’re hungry: straight to the i love new york pizza clifton park menu. This branch is known for its clean setting, fast service, and an emphasis on family-friendly comfort food with New York-style flair.

Whether you’re picking up dinner after work, grabbing a quick lunch on your break, or hosting a birthday party, this spot keeps it easy and delicious.

Menu Highlights at Clifton Park

• Extra Large Cheese Pie (20”) – Bigger than usual, feeds up to 6, and starts at $14.99.
• Meat Lovers Pizza – Bacon, sausage, ham, and pepperoni piled on.
• Veggie Supreme – Packed with mushrooms, olives, green peppers, onions, and fresh tomatoes.
• Buffalo Chicken Roll – A local favorite, golden-baked and filled to the edge.

Combo Meals That Actually Fill You Up

This location offers hearty combo deals perfect for families or hungry teens:

• Large Pie + Wings + 2 Liter Soda – Around $24.99
• 2 Rolls + Garlic Knots + Fountain Drink – Just $11.50
• Pasta Tray (Feeds 3–4) + Breadsticks – From $18.99

Clifton Park Perks & Extras

• Loyalty Card Program – Buy 10 pies, get 1 free (yep, old-school but it works)
• Party Tray Discounts – Great for office lunches or birthday gatherings
• Parking & Accessibility – Easy to pull in and out with plenty of space

Price Snapshot – Clifton Park

Comparing the i Love New York Pizza Menu Across Locations

If you’ve made it this far, you’re probably wondering—are all the I Love New York Pizza menus the same everywhere? Not exactly. While the core items stay consistent (cheese pies, pepperoni slices, garlic knots), each location adds its own local spin.

So let’s break it down and help you figure out which one might be your new go-to.

1. Albany vs Chapel Hill vs Clifton Park: Core Differences

Each menu is built around who’s eating. Albany caters to students pulling all-nighters. Chapel Hill leans into campus vibes and offers vegan-friendly options. Clifton Park plays to its strength: big pies, big portions, and family-style combos.

2. Pricing Trends

• Albany usually offers the best value for slices and student combos.
• Chapel Hill is a bit more premium but throws in extra perks (vegan cheese, student discounts).
• Clifton Park prices are slightly higher for pies, but the portion sizes and combo deals justify it.

3. Specialty Menu Items to Try Once

If you’re visiting a new branch, these are the one-time must-haves:

• Albany: White Pizza with Broccoli – light but satisfying
• Chapel Hill: Tar Heel Special – spicy and unique
• Clifton Park: Buffalo Chicken Roll – crispy, cheesy, perfect to-go snack

4. The Verdict? It Depends on What You Want

If you’re looking for:

• Late-night slices & student pricing → Albany
• Unique flavors & modern touches → Chapel Hill
• Big portions for families → Clifton Park

Every i love new york pizza menu offers quality. It’s more about which one matches your vibe, your hunger level, and your company.

Frequently Asked Questions: i Love New York Pizza Menu & Locations

Q1: What makes the i love new york pizza menu different from other pizza chains?

The biggest difference is authenticity. The i love new york pizza menu focuses on traditional New York-style pies—thin crust, large slices, and simple, flavorful toppings. While many chains overcomplicate things, here it’s about doing the basics right. Plus, each location adds local flair, which makes it feel more like a neighborhood joint than a franchise.

Q2: Does the i love new york pizza albany menu offer combo deals for students?

Yes, and they’re super popular! The i love new york pizza albany menu features budget-friendly combos perfect for SUNY students and nearby campuses. A common favorite is the 2 slices and a drink deal for under $7. You can also score late-night discounts and rotating specials throughout the week.

Q3: What’s the difference between the i love new york pizza albany menu and the i love new york pizza albany ny menu?

They’re actually the same! The term i love new york pizza albany ny menu is just a more specific search term that includes the state. It helps people looking for that exact location in Albany, New York, especially tourists or delivery customers using Google Maps. But menu-wise, there’s no difference.

Q4: What’s the most unique item on the i love new york pizza chapel hill menu?

Hands down, it’s the Tar Heel Special—a pie that features grilled chicken, jalapeños, ranch, and red onions. Exclusive to that store, it’s tailored to local tastes and student cravings. The i love new york pizza chapel hill menu also offers vegan cheese, which sets it apart from other branches.

Q5: Does the i love new york pizza clifton park menu have family meal options?

Absolutely. The i love new york pizza clifton park menu is known for generous portions and group-friendly deals. You’ll find combos like a large cheese pie, 10 wings, and a 2-liter soda all bundled for under $25. It’s perfect for quick family dinners, especially on busy weeknights.

Q6: Do all locations serve the same pizza sizes and toppings?

Mostly, yes. All branches stick to the New York-style basics—18” pies, foldable slices, and a wide range of toppings. However, local specials and seasonal offerings can vary. For example, Albany sometimes features Mac ‘n Cheese Pizza, while Clifton Park pushes calzones and rolls a bit more.

Q7: Can I customize my order at any location?

You sure can. Whether you’re gluten-sensitive, prefer extra cheese, or want half-and-half toppings, every location lets you build your own pizza. You’ll also find vegetarian and sometimes vegan options depending on the store.

Q8: Are there any health-conscious options on the i love new york pizza menu?

Yes, there are! Several locations offer thin crust, vegetarian pies, white pizzas with ricotta, and salads as lighter alternatives. While it’s still comfort food at its core, you can make healthier choices without missing out on flavor.

Q9: Do they offer delivery or only dine-in/takeout?

All locations offer delivery—either through their in-house drivers or third-party apps like DoorDash and Grubhub. So whether you’re craving the i love new york pizza albany ny menu from your dorm or ordering the i love new york pizza clifton park menu from your couch, you’re covered.

Q10: How do I find the closest location and full menu?

Search terms like i love new york pizza menu near me or include your city name (e.g., chapel hill, albany ny, clifton park) to get the full menu, pricing, and hours. You can also visit their official site or find their listings on Yelp and Google Business.

Final Thoughts: Why the i Love New York Pizza Menu Stays Winning

Pizza menus come and go, but there’s something timeless about the i love new york pizza menu. It’s not just about food—it’s about comfort, familiarity, and that feeling of walking into a place that knows exactly what you’re craving. Whether you’re ordering a quick lunch between classes in Albany, grabbing dinner with friends in Chapel Hill, or picking up a pie for family movie night in Clifton Park—this menu delivers more than just slices.

It delivers consistency. It delivers flavor. And maybe most importantly—it delivers value. Not just in dollars, but in experience. It’s the kind of place where you don’t need to overthink your order. You just show up, fold your slice, and take that first bite knowing it’s going to hit the spot.

So, the next time you’re in one of these cities and debating where to eat, you’ll know the answer. Because once you’ve been there, you don’t just love the pizza—you love the I Love New York Pizza experience.